Corrections
When we get something wrong, we fix it in the open and log it here. A public correction is a health signal, not an embarrassment — it is how an evidence-first project earns trust. Spotted an error? Tell us →
| Date | Film | Layer | What changed & why |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-10 | The Old Dark House (1932) | print, score, story | The film is NOT public domain: Universal renewed it on 17 June 1960 (R258433, listed in the 1960 Catalog of Copyright Entries), so it is protected until 1 January 2028. Film and music changed from 'Verified public domain' to 'Protected'. The source novel (Benighted, US 1928) is public domain. Our page said a full search of the 1959-60 renewal catalogs found nothing. We re-checked the 1960 catalog's full text ourselves and the renewal is there. The page went live on 10 October and was corrected the same day. |
| 2026-10-10 | The Shadow Returns (1946) | print, score | The film is NOT public domain: its copyright was renewed on 16 March 1973 (R548096, listed in the 1973 Catalog of Copyright Entries), so it is protected until 1 January 2042. The page had said Monogram never renewed it and that the footage was free to use. Found by our new automatic check, which reads the printed renewal catalogs instead of trusting a written claim that a search was done. |
| 2026-10-10 | McLintock! (1963) | score | Music changed from 'Undetermined' to 'Partly protected': the film's theme was renewed in 1991 (RE0000531720). Found by our new automatic renewal check against the Copyright Office records. |
| 2026-10-08 | Robin Hood (1922) | editorial | Fixed the film's facts: full title 'Douglas Fairbanks in Robin Hood' (not 'The Adventures of Robin Hood'), premiere October 18, 1922 at Grauman's Egyptian Theatre (the first Hollywood premiere), a reported $930,000 budget (not $1.4 million, and not called the most expensive film to date), and a 127-minute first release (not about 170 minutes). The rights verdicts did not change. Found in our own review before reusing the page text for a video. |
| 2026-10-07 | Plan 9 from Outer Space (1957) | print, story, score | Moved the film print, story and score from 'Verified public domain' back to 'Undetermined'. A renewal (RE0000279707, Wade Williams, 1986) is on record; the page called it invalid without a ruling to support that. Found by an independent audit of our research pipeline: an automated refresh treated a model's legal opinion as verified fact. |
| 2026-10-07 | King Kong (1933) | story | The 24 November 1976 ruling that the King Kong novel is public domain was later vacated after Universal and RKO settled, so it is not binding; a second 1976 ruling with the same finding (the 'Cooper Judgment') was reinstated. Universal v. Nintendo was a trademark case and did not rule on the story's copyright. Added that the novel's 95-year term ends on 1 January 2028. A reader on r/publicdomain pointed out that the 1976 decision was vacated (u/ScottRiqui); confirmed in Universal v. Nintendo, 578 F. Supp. 911 (S.D.N.Y. 1983). |
| 2026-10-06 | The Lost World (1925) | editorial | Bessie Love plays Paula White, daughter of the lost explorer Maple White; the page wrongly called her the companion of Challenger's daughter. Found in our own review before reusing the page text. |
| 2026-10-05 | Class of 2027 page (Little Caesar, Cimarron) | Removed Little Caesar and Cimarron from the films entering the public domain on 1 January 2027, and from the Class of 1931 dataset. Both are already public domain (since 1 January 2026). Both were registered for copyright in December 1930 although released in January 1931; the term runs from the 1930 date. Reported by a reader on r/publicdomain (u/Classicsarecool). | |
| 2026-10-05 | King Kong (1933) | story | Added the 1976 ruling (Judge Manuel Real) that the 1932 Lovelace novelization and its magazine serialization are public domain for non-renewal, alongside the later Universal v. Nintendo case. A reader on r/publicdomain pointed out that the novel's public-domain status comes from the 1976 Universal/RKO case, not the Nintendo case (u/FernWaltersOfficial). |
| 2026-10-05 | Restorations layer (62 films) | restorations | Changed the restorations layer from 'Protected' to 'Partly protected' on 62 films, with the rule explained: a faithful restoration of a public-domain film adds no new US copyright; new material (scores, colorization, new or translated titles) is protected; ripping copy-protected discs can break the DMCA's anti-circumvention rule. A reader on r/publicdomain pointed to Bridgeman v. Corel and Feist (u/DarrellMaclaine). Our blanket 'Protected' overstated the law. |
| 2026-07-12 | King Kong (1933) | story | Softened the 1932 novelization / underlying-story layer from an implied clean public-domain reading to 'partially protected — uncertain'. Community feedback (Reddit, u/Pawesome_James) correctly noted that Universal City Studios v. Nintendo turned on Universal's own lack of rights, not on the novelization's PD status, and LibriVox has not cleared the book. We had over-read the earlier note. Corrections are a health signal, not an embarrassment. |